Flow in Open Channels - Exam Answer Templates
In the PRC Civil Engineer Licensure Examination, Hydraulics problems on open-channel flow consistently appear in the board exam. Knowing the correct formula is only half the battle; presenting your solution in a clear, logical, and complete manner is what earns full marks. Examiners award marks for correct identification of given data, proper formula citation, dimensional consistency, correct arithmetic, and a stated final answer with units. These templates show you the exact format — step by step — that maximises your score at every mark level. Study the model answers as writing blueprints, not just answer keys.
Answer templates
Define hydraulic radius and state its formula.
Examiner tip
The single mark is awarded only if the ratio is correct. A verbal description without the formula does not earn the mark.
Model answer
The hydraulic radius R is the ratio of the cross-sectional flow area A to the wetted perimeter P of the channel:
R = A / P
It characterises the hydraulic efficiency of a channel cross-section.
Answer structure
- One sentence: define R as A/P — [1 mark]
Scoring breakdown
Criteria
Correct statement that R = A/P with identification of A as flow area and P as wetted perimeter.
Common mark deductions
- Writing P as the total perimeter instead of the wetted perimeter — loses the mark entirely.
- Confusing hydraulic radius with hydraulic diameter (D_h = 4R).
- Omitting the formula and writing only a vague description.
Key phrases to include
- hydraulic radius
- flow area
- wetted perimeter
- R = A/P
State Manning's equation for mean velocity in SI units and identify each variable.
Examiner tip
The coefficient '1' in the SI form is often omitted in writing but must be understood. Examiners expect the SI form explicitly.
Model answer
Manning's equation (SI):
v = (1/n) R^(2/3) S^(1/2)
where v = mean flow velocity (m/s), n = Manning roughness coefficient (dimensionless), R = hydraulic radius (m), S = channel bed slope (m/m, dimensionless).
Answer structure
- Write the formula — [0.5 mark]
- Identify all four variables with units — [0.5 mark]
Scoring breakdown
Criteria
Correct formula v = (1/n)R^(2/3)S^(1/2) with correct identification of n, R, and S.
Common mark deductions
- Using coefficient 1.49 (US customary form) instead of 1 (SI form) — incorrect for Philippine board exams.
- Writing S as percentage instead of a dimensionless ratio.
- Omitting the exponents 2/3 or 1/2.
Key phrases to include
- v = (1/n)R^(2/3)S^(1/2)
- Manning roughness coefficient
- hydraulic radius
- bed slope
What are the dimensions of the most efficient rectangular open channel cross-section? Explain briefly.
Examiner tip
Always give the physical reason (minimum P → maximum R → maximum Q) for concept questions; this earns the second mark.
Model answer
For the most efficient (best hydraulic) rectangular section, the channel width b equals twice the flow depth y:
b = 2y
This condition minimises the wetted perimeter P for a given flow area A, which maximises the hydraulic radius R = A/P and therefore maximises discharge Q for a fixed slope S and roughness n. Under this condition, R = y/2.
Answer structure
- Line 1: State the condition b = 2y — [1 mark]
- Line 2: Explain that this minimises P (or maximises R), maximising Q — [1 mark]
Scoring breakdown
Criteria
Correctly states b = 2y (or equivalently y = b/2).
Criteria
Correctly explains that minimum wetted perimeter maximises hydraulic radius and discharge.
Common mark deductions
- Stating only b = 2y without any justification — earns only 1 of 2 marks.
- Confusing 'most efficient' with 'maximum area' rather than minimum wetted perimeter.
- Incorrect statement such as b = y.
Key phrases to include
- b = 2y
- minimum wetted perimeter
- maximum hydraulic radius
- R = y/2
Define specific energy in open-channel flow and write its formula for a rectangular channel.
Examiner tip
The key distinguishing phrase is 'referenced to the channel bottom as datum' — this differentiates specific energy from total hydraulic energy.
Model answer
Specific energy E is the total energy per unit weight of flowing water measured from the channel bottom as datum:
E = y + v²/(2g)
where y = flow depth (m), v = mean velocity (m/s), and g = 9.81 m/s². The first term y is the potential (depth) component and the second term v²/(2g) is the velocity head. For a rectangular channel with unit discharge q = Q/b, this becomes:
E = y + q²/(2g y²)
Answer structure
- Line 1: Define E as energy per unit weight above the channel bottom — [1 mark]
- Line 2: Write the correct formula E = y + v²/(2g) with variable identification — [1 mark]
Scoring breakdown
Criteria
Correct definition: energy per unit weight referenced to the channel bed.
Criteria
Correct formula E = y + v²/(2g) with proper identification of terms.
Common mark deductions
- Referencing datum to a different point (e.g., sea level) rather than the channel bottom.
- Omitting the velocity head term.
- Using total head H (which includes elevation z) instead of specific energy E.
Key phrases to include
- energy per unit weight
- channel bottom datum
- E = y + v²/(2g)
- depth component
- velocity head
A rectangular channel 3 m wide carries flow at a depth of 1.2 m with a mean velocity of 1.86 m/s. Determine the Froude number and classify the flow.
Examiner tip
Always write the classification statement explicitly — 'Fr = 0.54 < 1, therefore subcritical.' Without the classification, the second mark is at risk.
Model answer
Given:
b = 3 m, y = 1.2 m, v = 1.86 m/s, g = 9.81 m/s²
Required: Froude number Fr and flow classification
Solution:
Fr = v / √(g·y)
Fr = 1.86 / √(9.81 × 1.2)
Fr = 1.86 / √11.772
Fr = 1.86 / 3.431
Fr = 0.542
Since Fr < 1, the flow is SUBCRITICAL (tranquil).
Answer structure
- Line 1–2: Write Given data and Required — [0 marks but required structure]
- Line 3: State formula Fr = v/√(gy) — [1 mark]
- Line 4–5: Substitute and compute Fr = 0.542 — [0.5 mark]
- Line 6: Classify as subcritical since Fr < 1 — [0.5 mark]
Scoring breakdown
Criteria
Correct formula Fr = v/√(gy) applied with correct values.
Criteria
Correct numerical result Fr ≈ 0.54 and correct classification as subcritical.
Common mark deductions
- Using Fr = v/√(g) without the depth in the denominator.
- Classifying incorrectly (e.g., calling Fr = 0.54 supercritical).
- Forgetting to take the square root of g·y.
Key phrases to include
- Fr = v/√(gy)
- Fr < 1
- subcritical
- tranquil flow
A rectangular channel (b = 3 m) carries Q = 6 m³/s. Determine the critical depth y_c and the minimum specific energy E_min.
Examiner tip
The formula E_min = (3/2)y_c is specific to rectangular channels — mention this qualifier to show depth of knowledge.
Model answer
Given:
b = 3 m, Q = 6 m³/s, g = 9.81 m/s²
Required: Critical depth y_c and minimum specific energy E_min
Solution:
Step 1 — Unit discharge:
q = Q/b = 6/3 = 2.0 m²/s (m³/s per metre width)
Step 2 — Critical depth:
y_c = (q²/g)^(1/3)
y_c = (2.0²/9.81)^(1/3)
y_c = (4.0/9.81)^(1/3)
y_c = (0.4077)^(1/3)
y_c = 0.742 m
Step 3 — Minimum specific energy:
E_min = (3/2) y_c = 1.5 × 0.742 = 1.113 m ≈ 1.11 m
Answer: y_c = 0.742 m; E_min = 1.11 m
Answer structure
- Step 1: Compute q = Q/b — [1 mark]
- Step 2: Apply y_c = (q²/g)^(1/3) and solve — [1 mark]
- Step 3: Apply E_min = (3/2)y_c — [1 mark]
Scoring breakdown
Criteria
Correct computation of unit discharge q = Q/b = 2.0 m²/s.
Criteria
Correct application of y_c = (q²/g)^(1/3) giving y_c ≈ 0.742 m.
Criteria
Correct application of E_min = (3/2)y_c giving E_min ≈ 1.11 m.
Common mark deductions
- Using Q instead of q (unit discharge) directly in the formula without dividing by b.
- Applying the exponent as 1/2 instead of 1/3.
- Forgetting the E_min = 1.5 y_c relationship and computing E from scratch with errors.
Key phrases to include
- q = Q/b
- y_c = (q²/g)^(1/3)
- E_min = (3/2)y_c
Using Manning's equation, compute the discharge in a rectangular channel: width b = 3 m, depth y = 1.2 m, Manning's n = 0.013, bed slope S = 0.001.
Examiner tip
Show the intermediate value R^(2/3) and S^(1/2) separately before multiplying — this demonstrates systematic computation and earns partial credit even with a later arithmetic error.
Model answer
Given:
b = 3 m, y = 1.2 m, n = 0.013, S = 0.001
Required: Discharge Q (m³/s)
Solution:
Step 1 — Cross-sectional area and wetted perimeter:
A = b × y = 3 × 1.2 = 3.60 m²
P = b + 2y = 3 + 2(1.2) = 3 + 2.4 = 5.40 m
Step 2 — Hydraulic radius:
R = A/P = 3.60/5.40 = 0.6667 m
Step 3 — Manning's velocity (SI form):
v = (1/n) R^(2/3) S^(1/2)
v = (1/0.013)(0.6667)^(2/3)(0.001)^(1/2)
v = 76.923 × 0.7631 × 0.031623
v = 1.856 m/s ≈ 1.86 m/s
Step 4 — Discharge:
Q = Av = 3.60 × 1.856 = 6.68 m³/s
Answer: Q ≈ 6.68 m³/s
Answer structure
- Step 1: Compute A and P correctly — [1 mark]
- Step 2: Compute R = A/P — [0.5 mark]
- Step 3: Apply Manning's equation, compute v — [1 mark]
- Step 4: Compute Q = Av with units — [0.5 mark]
Scoring breakdown
Criteria
Correct area A = 3.60 m² and wetted perimeter P = 5.40 m.
Criteria
Correct hydraulic radius R = 0.667 m and correct substitution into Manning's equation.
Criteria
Correct final discharge Q ≈ 6.68 m³/s with units.
Common mark deductions
- Using P = 2b + 2y (full perimeter) instead of P = b + 2y (wetted perimeter for open channel).
- Computing R^(2/3) incorrectly — use logarithms or direct computation: 0.6667^(2/3) = e^(2/3 × ln 0.6667) = 0.763.
- Using 1.49 as the Manning constant (US customary) instead of 1 (SI).
- Forgetting to compute Q = Av after finding v.
Key phrases to include
- R = A/P
- v = (1/n)R^(2/3)S^(1/2)
- Q = Av
- wetted perimeter
A hydraulic jump occurs in a rectangular channel. The upstream (supercritical) depth is y₁ = 0.40 m and the upstream velocity is v₁ = 6.0 m/s. Find the sequent (conjugate) depth y₂.
Examiner tip
Always verify the jump condition (Fr₁ > 1) with a tick mark (✓) — examiners reward this check as it shows conceptual understanding.
Model answer
Given:
y₁ = 0.40 m, v₁ = 6.0 m/s, g = 9.81 m/s²
Required: Sequent depth y₂
Solution:
Step 1 — Froude number upstream:
Fr₁ = v₁/√(g·y₁)
Fr₁ = 6.0/√(9.81 × 0.40)
Fr₁ = 6.0/√3.924
Fr₁ = 6.0/1.981 = 3.029
Since Fr₁ = 3.03 > 1, the flow is supercritical — a hydraulic jump can occur. ✓
Step 2 — Conjugate depth formula:
y₂/y₁ = (1/2)[√(1 + 8·Fr₁²) − 1]
y₂/0.40 = (1/2)[√(1 + 8 × 3.029²) − 1]
y₂/0.40 = (1/2)[√(1 + 8 × 9.175) − 1]
y₂/0.40 = (1/2)[√(1 + 73.40) − 1]
y₂/0.40 = (1/2)[√74.40 − 1]
y₂/0.40 = (1/2)[8.626 − 1]
y₂/0.40 = (1/2)(7.626) = 3.813
Step 3:
y₂ = 0.40 × 3.813 = 1.525 m ≈ 1.53 m
Answer: y₂ ≈ 1.53 m
Answer structure
- Step 1: Compute Fr₁ and verify Fr₁ > 1 — [1 mark]
- Step 2: State and apply conjugate-depth formula correctly — [1 mark]
- Step 3: Compute y₂ with units — [1 mark]
Scoring breakdown
Criteria
Correct Fr₁ = v₁/√(gy₁) ≈ 3.03 and explicit verification that Fr₁ > 1.
Criteria
Correct formula y₂/y₁ = (1/2)[√(1 + 8Fr₁²) − 1] with correct substitution.
Criteria
Correct final answer y₂ ≈ 1.53 m with units.
Common mark deductions
- Not verifying Fr₁ > 1 before applying the jump formula.
- Using Fr₁² as Fr₁ × 2 rather than Fr₁ squared.
- Applying the formula as y₂/y₁ = (1/2)(√(1 + 8Fr₁²) + 1) — wrong sign, plus instead of minus.
Key phrases to include
- Fr₁ = v₁/√(gy₁)
- Fr₁ > 1 supercritical
- y₂/y₁ = (1/2)[√(1 + 8Fr₁²) − 1]
- conjugate depth
- sequent depth
Describe the concept of the hydraulic jump. What physical phenomenon causes it and what happens to the specific energy across the jump?
Examiner tip
Mention the practical application (stilling basin, energy dissipator) to show engineering context — examiners appreciate applied understanding.
Model answer
A hydraulic jump is an abrupt, localised transition from supercritical flow (Fr > 1) to subcritical flow (Fr < 1) in an open channel. It occurs when a high-velocity, shallow flow (e.g., at the base of a spillway or sluice gate) encounters a downstream condition that forces it to decelerate.
Physically, the transition is caused by the momentum imbalance between the high-velocity supercritical stream and the lower-velocity subcritical regime downstream. The jump is characterised by intense turbulence, surface rollers, and significant air entrainment.
Specific energy is NOT conserved across the jump — a portion of the upstream kinetic energy is irreversibly converted into heat (internal energy) by turbulence. Therefore:
E₂ < E₁ (energy loss ΔE = E₁ − E₂ > 0)
This energy dissipation makes the hydraulic jump useful as a natural stilling basin to protect channel structures from erosion.
Answer structure
- Part 1: Define the hydraulic jump (supercritical → subcritical transition) — [1 mark]
- Part 2: Explain the physical cause (momentum imbalance, turbulence) — [1 mark]
- Part 3: State that specific energy decreases across the jump (E₂ < E₁) — [1 mark]
Scoring breakdown
Criteria
Correct definition: abrupt transition from supercritical (Fr > 1) to subcritical (Fr < 1) flow.
Criteria
Correct physical explanation: turbulence, momentum change, energy dissipation.
Criteria
Correct statement that specific energy is lost across the jump (E₂ < E₁).
Common mark deductions
- Saying energy is conserved across the jump — this is wrong; energy is dissipated.
- Describing the jump as occurring from subcritical to supercritical — the direction is reversed.
- Not mentioning the Froude number condition.
Key phrases to include
- supercritical to subcritical
- Fr > 1 upstream
- turbulence
- energy dissipation
- E₂ < E₁
- stilling basin
A trapezoidal channel has a bottom width b = 4 m, side slopes of 1.5H:1V, depth y = 1.5 m, Manning's n = 0.015, and bed slope S = 0.0008. Calculate the discharge Q.
Examiner tip
The most common error in trapezoidal channels is the wetted perimeter. Write the formula P = b + 2y√(1+z²) explicitly before substituting numbers to signal to the examiner you know the correct geometry.
Model answer
Given:
b = 4 m, side slope z = 1.5 (horizontal:vertical), y = 1.5 m
n = 0.015, S = 0.0008
Required: Discharge Q (m³/s)
Solution:
Step 1 — Cross-sectional area (trapezoidal):
A = (b + z·y)·y
A = (4 + 1.5 × 1.5)(1.5)
A = (4 + 2.25)(1.5)
A = 6.25 × 1.5
A = 9.375 m²
Step 2 — Wetted perimeter:
Side length = y√(1 + z²) = 1.5√(1 + 1.5²) = 1.5√(1 + 2.25) = 1.5√3.25
Side length = 1.5 × 1.8028 = 2.704 m
P = b + 2 × side length = 4 + 2(2.704) = 4 + 5.408 = 9.408 m
Step 3 — Hydraulic radius:
R = A/P = 9.375/9.408 = 0.9965 m ≈ 0.997 m
Step 4 — Manning's velocity (SI):
v = (1/n)·R^(2/3)·S^(1/2)
R^(2/3) = (0.9965)^(2/3) ≈ 0.9977
S^(1/2) = (0.0008)^(1/2) = 0.02828
v = (1/0.015)(0.9977)(0.02828)
v = 66.667 × 0.9977 × 0.02828
v = 1.882 m/s
Step 5 — Discharge:
Q = A·v = 9.375 × 1.882
Q = 17.64 m³/s ≈ 17.6 m³/s
Answer: Q ≈ 17.6 m³/s
Answer structure
- Step 1: Correct trapezoidal area formula A = (b + zy)y — [1 mark]
- Step 2: Correct wetted perimeter with inclined side length = y√(1+z²) — [1 mark]
- Step 3: Hydraulic radius R = A/P — [1 mark]
- Step 4: Manning's velocity with correct exponents — [1 mark]
- Step 5: Q = Av with units — [1 mark]
Scoring breakdown
Criteria
Correct area A = (b + zy)y = 9.375 m².
Criteria
Correct inclined side length = y√(1+z²) and wetted perimeter P = 9.408 m.
Criteria
Correct hydraulic radius R = A/P ≈ 0.997 m.
Criteria
Correct application of Manning's formula giving v ≈ 1.88 m/s.
Criteria
Correct final discharge Q ≈ 17.6 m³/s with SI units.
Common mark deductions
- Using A = by (rectangular formula) instead of the trapezoidal formula.
- Using P = b + 2y (vertical sides) instead of P = b + 2y√(1+z²) for inclined sides.
- Plugging in S = 0.08% as 0.08 rather than 0.0008.
- Not showing intermediate computations — difficult to award partial marks.
Key phrases to include
- A = (b + zy)y
- side length = y√(1+z²)
- R = A/P
- v = (1/n)R^(2/3)S^(1/2)
- Q = Av
Design the most efficient rectangular channel cross-section to carry Q = 5.0 m³/s with Manning's n = 0.013 and bed slope S = 0.001. Determine the required width b and depth y.
Examiner tip
This is a classic design problem. The first and most critical step is invoking b = 2y — write it prominently. Board examiners give 1 mark just for this correct starting condition.
Model answer
Given:
Q = 5.0 m³/s, n = 0.013, S = 0.001
Required: Width b and depth y for the most efficient rectangular section.
Concept: For the most efficient rectangular section, b = 2y, and R = y/2.
Solution:
Step 1 — Express A and R in terms of y only:
Since b = 2y:
A = b·y = 2y·y = 2y²
P = b + 2y = 2y + 2y = 4y
R = A/P = 2y²/(4y) = y/2
Step 2 — Apply Manning's equation:
Q = A·v = A·(1/n)·R^(2/3)·S^(1/2)
5.0 = 2y² × (1/0.013) × (y/2)^(2/3) × (0.001)^(1/2)
Step 3 — Evaluate known constants:
(1/n) = 1/0.013 = 76.923
S^(1/2) = (0.001)^(1/2) = 0.031623
(y/2)^(2/3) = y^(2/3) / 2^(2/3) = y^(2/3) / 1.5874
Step 4 — Combine:
5.0 = 2y² × 76.923 × [y^(2/3)/1.5874] × 0.031623
5.0 = 2y² × 76.923 × 0.031623 × y^(2/3) / 1.5874
5.0 = 2 × 76.923 × 0.031623 / 1.5874 × y^(8/3)
5.0 = 2 × 1.5320 × y^(8/3)
5.0 = 3.0640 × y^(8/3)
Step 5 — Solve for y:
y^(8/3) = 5.0/3.0640 = 1.6319
y = (1.6319)^(3/8)
ln y = (3/8) × ln(1.6319) = 0.375 × 0.4894 = 0.1835
y = e^(0.1835) = 1.2016 m ≈ 1.20 m
Step 6 — Width:
b = 2y = 2 × 1.20 = 2.40 m
Verification:
A = 2(1.20)² = 2.88 m², R = 1.20/2 = 0.60 m
v = (1/0.013)(0.60)^(2/3)(0.001)^(1/2) = 76.923 × 0.7114 × 0.031623 = 1.730 m/s
Q = 2.88 × 1.730 = 4.98 ≈ 5.0 m³/s ✓
Answer: y ≈ 1.20 m, b = 2y ≈ 2.40 m
Answer structure
- State the condition b = 2y and R = y/2 — [1 mark]
- Express A and R solely in terms of y — [1 mark]
- Set up Manning's equation with Q = 5.0 m³/s — [1 mark]
- Solve for y algebraically — [1 mark]
- Find b = 2y and verify (optional but rewarded) — [1 mark]
Scoring breakdown
Criteria
Correctly applies the condition b = 2y and R = y/2 for most efficient section.
Criteria
Correctly expresses A = 2y² and R = y/2 as functions of y only.
Criteria
Correctly substitutes into Q = A·(1/n)·R^(2/3)·S^(1/2) to get an equation in y only.
Criteria
Correct solution y ≈ 1.20 m.
Criteria
Correct width b = 2y ≈ 2.40 m and/or verification of Q.
Common mark deductions
- Setting up the equation without first applying the b = 2y condition — introduces two unknowns, making the equation unsolvable.
- Algebraic errors when combining the y^2 and y^(2/3) exponents — the correct combined exponent is y^(8/3).
- Not verifying the answer — missing the chance to catch arithmetic errors.
Key phrases to include
- b = 2y
- R = y/2
- most efficient rectangular section
- Q = A(1/n)R^(2/3)S^(1/2)
- y^(8/3)
Water flows in a rectangular channel with q = 3.0 m²/s. Determine: (a) critical depth y_c, (b) minimum specific energy E_min, and (c) critical velocity v_c.
Examiner tip
Always verify your critical depth result by checking Fr = 1. This double-check takes 15 seconds and can earn an extra mark while confirming your answer.
Model answer
Given:
Unit discharge q = 3.0 m²/s (m³/s per metre width), g = 9.81 m/s²
Required: y_c, E_min, v_c
Solution:
(a) Critical depth:
y_c = (q²/g)^(1/3)
y_c = (3.0²/9.81)^(1/3)
y_c = (9.0/9.81)^(1/3)
y_c = (0.9174)^(1/3)
y_c = 0.9713 m ≈ 0.971 m
(b) Minimum specific energy:
E_min = (3/2)·y_c
E_min = 1.5 × 0.9713
E_min = 1.457 m ≈ 1.46 m
Verification using E = y + v²/2g:
v_c = q/y_c = 3.0/0.9713 = 3.088 m/s
E = 0.9713 + (3.088)²/(2×9.81) = 0.9713 + 0.4856 = 1.457 m ✓
(c) Critical velocity:
v_c = q/y_c = 3.0/0.9713 = 3.09 m/s
Check: Fr_c = v_c/√(g·y_c) = 3.09/√(9.81×0.9713) = 3.09/3.09 = 1.00 ✓ (critical)
Answer:
(a) y_c = 0.971 m
(b) E_min = 1.46 m
(c) v_c = 3.09 m/s
Answer structure
- (a) Apply y_c = (q²/g)^(1/3) — [2 marks]
- (b) Apply E_min = (3/2)y_c — [1 mark]
- (c) Compute v_c = q/y_c — [1 mark]
- Froude number check Fr = 1 confirms critical condition — [1 mark]
Scoring breakdown
Criteria
Correct formula and computation of y_c = (q²/g)^(1/3) ≈ 0.971 m.
Criteria
Correct E_min = (3/2)y_c ≈ 1.46 m.
Criteria
Correct critical velocity v_c = q/y_c ≈ 3.09 m/s.
Criteria
Froude number verification Fr = v_c/√(gy_c) = 1.00 confirming critical condition.
Common mark deductions
- Using Q instead of q (unit discharge per metre width) — dimensional error.
- Forgetting to verify Fr = 1 at the critical condition — missed mark.
- Computing E_min independently as y_c + v_c²/2g without using the E_min = 1.5y_c shortcut (still correct but error-prone).
Key phrases to include
- y_c = (q²/g)^(1/3)
- E_min = (3/2)y_c
- v_c = q/y_c
- Fr = 1 at critical flow
A hydraulic jump occurs in a 4-m wide rectangular channel. The upstream depth is y₁ = 0.5 m and the discharge is Q = 10 m³/s. Determine: (a) upstream Froude number Fr₁, (b) conjugate depth y₂, and (c) head loss h_L across the jump.
Examiner tip
The alternative formula h_L = (y₂−y₁)³/(4y₁y₂) is the direct hydraulic jump head-loss formula — knowing and applying it as a check demonstrates mastery and impresses examiners.
Model answer
Given:
b = 4 m, y₁ = 0.5 m, Q = 10 m³/s, g = 9.81 m/s²
Required: Fr₁, y₂, h_L
Solution:
Step 1 — Upstream velocity and Froude number:
v₁ = Q/(b·y₁) = 10/(4 × 0.5) = 10/2 = 5.0 m/s
Fr₁ = v₁/√(g·y₁) = 5.0/√(9.81 × 0.5) = 5.0/√4.905 = 5.0/2.214 = 2.259
Fr₁ = 2.26 > 1 → supercritical flow confirmed ✓
Step 2 — Conjugate depth:
y₂/y₁ = (1/2)[√(1 + 8·Fr₁²) − 1]
y₂/0.5 = (1/2)[√(1 + 8 × 2.259²) − 1]
y₂/0.5 = (1/2)[√(1 + 8 × 5.103) − 1]
y₂/0.5 = (1/2)[√(1 + 40.82) − 1]
y₂/0.5 = (1/2)[√41.82 − 1]
y₂/0.5 = (1/2)[6.467 − 1]
y₂/0.5 = (1/2)(5.467) = 2.734
y₂ = 0.5 × 2.734 = 1.367 m ≈ 1.37 m
Step 3 — Downstream velocity:
v₂ = Q/(b·y₂) = 10/(4 × 1.367) = 10/5.468 = 1.829 m/s
Step 4 — Head loss (energy loss across the jump):
E₁ = y₁ + v₁²/(2g) = 0.5 + 5.0²/(2×9.81) = 0.5 + 1.274 = 1.774 m
E₂ = y₂ + v₂²/(2g) = 1.367 + 1.829²/(2×9.81) = 1.367 + 0.170 = 1.537 m
h_L = E₁ − E₂ = 1.774 − 1.537 = 0.237 m
Alternatively: h_L = (y₂ − y₁)³ / (4·y₁·y₂)
h_L = (1.367 − 0.5)³ / (4 × 0.5 × 1.367) = (0.867)³ / (2.734)
h_L = 0.652 / 2.734 = 0.238 m ✓
Answer:
(a) Fr₁ = 2.26 (supercritical)
(b) y₂ = 1.37 m
(c) h_L ≈ 0.237 m
Answer structure
- Step 1: Compute v₁ = Q/(by₁) and Fr₁ — [1 mark]
- Step 2: Apply conjugate-depth formula to find y₂ — [2 marks]
- Step 3: Compute v₂ — [0.5 mark]
- Step 4: Compute E₁, E₂, and h_L = E₁ − E₂ — [1.5 marks]
Scoring breakdown
Criteria
Correct Fr₁ = v₁/√(gy₁) ≈ 2.26 with verification Fr₁ > 1.
Criteria
Correct formula and computation of conjugate depth y₂ ≈ 1.37 m.
Criteria
Correct downstream specific energy E₂ and head loss h_L ≈ 0.237 m.
Criteria
Correct E₁ computation and final h_L = E₁ − E₂ with units.
Common mark deductions
- Forgetting to compute v₁ = Q/(by₁) before computing Fr₁.
- Arithmetic errors in Fr₁² — squaring Fr₁ first before multiplying by 8.
- Not computing the energy loss and leaving the answer at y₂ only.
Key phrases to include
- v₁ = Q/(by₁)
- Fr₁ = v₁/√(gy₁)
- y₂/y₁ = (1/2)[√(1+8Fr₁²)−1]
- h_L = E₁ − E₂
- (y₂−y₁)³/(4y₁y₂)
Compare subcritical and supercritical flow. List two characteristics of each.
Examiner tip
The downstream-control concept for subcritical and upstream-control concept for supercritical is a higher-order understanding that distinguishes above-average answers.
Model answer
Subcritical flow (Fr < 1):
- Flow is deep and slow (tranquil); gravity forces dominate over inertial forces.
- Disturbances propagate both upstream and downstream — downstream conditions control the flow.
Supercritical flow (Fr > 1):
- Flow is shallow and fast (rapid/shooting); inertial forces dominate over gravity forces.
- Disturbances can only propagate downstream — upstream conditions are unaffected by changes downstream.
Answer structure
- Two characteristics of subcritical flow (Fr < 1) — [1 mark]
- Two characteristics of supercritical flow (Fr > 1) — [1 mark]
Scoring breakdown
Criteria
Two correct characteristics of subcritical flow with Fr < 1 stated.
Criteria
Two correct characteristics of supercritical flow with Fr > 1 stated.
Common mark deductions
- Reversing the descriptions (calling Fr > 1 slow/deep).
- Omitting the Froude number values — the answer must reference Fr.
- Listing only one characteristic per flow type.
Key phrases to include
- Fr < 1 subcritical
- Fr > 1 supercritical
- deep and slow
- shallow and fast
- downstream control
- upstream propagation
State the conditions for the most efficient trapezoidal channel section.
Examiner tip
The key numbers to memorise: 60° angle and R = y/2. These two facts earn the mark in 1-mark VSA questions.
Model answer
The most efficient trapezoidal section is a half-hexagon: the three sides (bottom and two inclined sides) are all equal in length, the side slopes are at 60° from the horizontal (side slope z = 1/√3 ≈ 0.577H:1V), and the hydraulic radius equals half the depth: R = y/2.
Answer structure
- One statement: half-hexagon, equal sides, 60° inclination, R = y/2 — [1 mark]
Scoring breakdown
Criteria
Correct statement that the best trapezoidal section is a half-hexagon with sides at 60° and R = y/2.
Common mark deductions
- Stating 45° or 30° instead of 60°.
- Confusing this with the rectangular best section (b = 2y).
- Omitting R = y/2.
Key phrases to include
- half-hexagon
- 60° from horizontal
- equal sides
- R = y/2
Mark wise strategy
State the formula or definition directly and concisely. No derivation needed. Every word must carry information — eliminate filler phrases.
Do
- Write the exact formula (e.g., R = A/P) on the first line.
- Identify each symbol in the formula briefly.
- Use engineering shorthand where accepted (e.g., Fr for Froude number).
- State SI units for the answer if it is a formula for a quantity.
Don't
- Do not write lengthy explanations or derivations — wastes time.
- Do not omit the formula and rely on words alone — likely to lose the mark.
- Do not confuse similar-looking formulas (e.g., R = A/P versus D_h = 4R).
For conceptual 2-mark questions: state the fact AND provide the justification or example. For numerical 2-mark questions: write the formula, substitute, and state the answer with units and classification if applicable.
Do
- Use the Given / Required / Solution structure even for 2-mark numericals.
- State the formula explicitly before substituting numbers.
- Include the unit in the final answer line.
- For Froude number questions, always state the flow classification.
Don't
- Do not skip intermediate steps — partial credit is awarded per step.
- Do not round excessively during intermediate calculations.
- Do not omit units in the final answer.
Break the solution into numbered steps, each earning one mark. Each step should have: (1) formula, (2) substitution with numbers, (3) computed result with units. For concept questions: define, explain mechanism, state engineering significance.
Do
- Number your steps (Step 1, Step 2, Step 3).
- Box or underline your intermediate results (A, P, R) so the examiner can check them.
- Write the answer as a clear boxed final statement.
- Verify the result if time permits (e.g., check Fr = 1 for critical depth).
Don't
- Do not skip the hydraulic radius calculation — it is always an intermediate mark.
- Do not mix up Manning's SI and US customary forms.
- Do not omit the classification step for Froude number or jump problems.
Plan before writing. Identify all five marks (usually: area, perimeter, R, Manning velocity, discharge). Write each step on a separate line with formula, substitution, and result. Include a verification step at the end if possible. For design problems, state the governing condition (e.g., b = 2y) as Step 1 to earn the first mark immediately.
Do
- Allocate one step per mark — 5-mark problems typically have exactly 5 computable steps.
- State the governing design condition (e.g., most efficient section) at the very start.
- Show all intermediate computations (R^(2/3), S^(1/2)) as separate sub-results.
- Write a summary box at the end listing all required answers.
- Verify using an alternative formula where one exists (e.g., head-loss formula for hydraulic jump).
Don't
- Do not rush past the area and perimeter formulas — they carry 2 of the 5 marks.
- Do not skip the Given/Required section — it helps you organise and shows the examiner your understanding of the problem.
- Do not leave blanks — a partially correct step still earns partial credit.
- Do not use the US customary Manning constant 1.49 in Philippine board exams.
General answer writing tips
- Always write a 'Given / Required / Solution' heading structure for any numerical problem worth 2 marks or more — examiners follow this framework when checking.
- State the formula explicitly before substituting values; partial credit is often awarded for the correct formula even if arithmetic errors follow.
- Include SI units at every step of computation, not just the final answer. A dimensionally inconsistent line signals a conceptual error to the examiner.
- For Manning's equation, explicitly confirm whether you are using SI form (coefficient = 1) or US customary form (coefficient = 1.49); always use SI in Philippine board exams.
- When computing hydraulic radius R = A/P, show A and P separately before dividing — this earns intermediate marks and prevents sign/arithmetic errors.
- Classify flow as subcritical, critical, or supercritical by stating the Froude number result and the corresponding inequality (Fr < 1, = 1, > 1).
- Round intermediate values to at least four significant figures; only round the final answer to three significant figures unless the problem specifies otherwise.
- For hydraulic jump problems, always verify Fr₁ > 1 (supercritical approach) before applying the conjugate-depth formula — failure to verify is a common mark deduction.
Diagrams
Open Channel Flow — Key Concepts Overview
A comprehensive mind map showing all major topics in open-channel flow: uniform flow with Manning's equation, most efficient sections, specific energy, Froude number classification, critical flow, and hydraulic jump. Use this to orient yourself before studying the individual answer templates.
Step-by-Step Solution Guide — Manning's Discharge Problem
A decision-tree flowchart showing the systematic 5-step procedure for solving Manning's discharge problems for both rectangular and trapezoidal channels. Follow this flowchart to avoid missing intermediate steps that carry marks.
Hydraulic Jump Solution Procedure
A step-by-step flowchart for solving hydraulic jump problems. It enforces the critical verification step (Fr₁ > 1) before applying the conjugate-depth formula, and guides the student through the energy loss computation if required.
Flow Regime Transitions in Open Channels
A state diagram illustrating the transitions between subcritical, critical, and supercritical flow regimes. The hydraulic jump is shown as the direct abrupt transition from supercritical to subcritical. Use this to understand how flow regimes relate to each other conceptually.